feat: implement three-tier model strategy with Opus 4.5 (#139)

* feat: implement three-tier model strategy with Opus 4.5

This implements a strategic model selection approach based on agent
complexity and use case, addressing Issue #136.

Three-Tier Strategy:
- Tier 1 (opus): 17 critical agents for architecture, security, code review
- Tier 2 (inherit): 21 complex agents where users choose their model
- Tier 3 (sonnet): 63 routine development agents (unchanged)
- Tier 4 (haiku): 47 fast operational agents (unchanged)

Why Opus 4.5 for Tier 1:
- 80.9% on SWE-bench (industry-leading for code)
- 65% fewer tokens for long-horizon tasks
- Superior reasoning for architectural decisions

Changes:
- Update architect-review, cloud-architect, kubernetes-architect,
  database-architect, security-auditor, code-reviewer to opus
- Update backend-architect, performance-engineer, ai-engineer,
  prompt-engineer, ml-engineer, mlops-engineer, data-scientist,
  blockchain-developer, quant-analyst, risk-manager, sql-pro,
  database-optimizer to inherit
- Update README with three-tier model documentation

Relates to #136

* feat: comprehensive model tier redistribution for Opus 4.5

This commit implements a strategic rebalancing of agent model assignments,
significantly increasing the use of Opus 4.5 for critical coding tasks while
ensuring Sonnet is used more than Haiku for support tasks.

Final Distribution (153 total agent files):
- Tier 1 Opus: 42 agents (27.5%) - All production coding + critical architecture
- Tier 2 Inherit: 42 agents (27.5%) - Complex tasks, user-choosable
- Tier 3 Sonnet: 38 agents (24.8%) - Support tasks needing intelligence
- Tier 4 Haiku: 31 agents (20.3%) - Simple operational tasks

Key Changes:

Tier 1 (Opus) - Production Coding + Critical Review:
- ALL code-reviewers (6 total): Ensures highest quality code review across
  all contexts (comprehensive, git PR, code docs, codebase cleanup, refactoring, TDD)
- All major language pros (7): python, golang, rust, typescript, cpp, java, c
- Framework specialists (6): django (2), fastapi (2), graphql-architect (2)
- Complex specialists (6): terraform-specialist (3), tdd-orchestrator (2), data-engineer
- Blockchain: blockchain-developer (smart contracts are critical)
- Game dev (2): unity-developer, minecraft-bukkit-pro
- Architecture (existing): architect-review, cloud-architect, kubernetes-architect,
  hybrid-cloud-architect, database-architect, security-auditor

Tier 2 (Inherit) - User Flexibility:
- Secondary languages (6): javascript, scala, csharp, ruby, php, elixir
- All frontend/mobile (8): frontend-developer (4), mobile-developer (2),
  flutter-expert, ios-developer
- Specialized (6): observability-engineer (2), temporal-python-pro,
  arm-cortex-expert, context-manager (2), database-optimizer (2)
- AI/ML, backend-architect, performance-engineer, quant/risk (existing)

Tier 3 (Sonnet) - Intelligent Support:
- Documentation (4): docs-architect (2), tutorial-engineer (2)
- Testing (2): test-automator (2)
- Developer experience (3): dx-optimizer (2), business-analyst
- Modernization (4): legacy-modernizer (3), database-admin
- Other support agents (existing)

Tier 4 (Haiku) - Simple Operations:
- SEO/Marketing (10): All SEO agents, content, search
- Deployment (4): deployment-engineer (4 instances)
- Debugging (5): debugger (2), error-detective (3)
- DevOps (3): devops-troubleshooter (3)
- Other simple operational tasks

Rationale:
- Opus 4.5 achieves 80.9% on SWE-bench with 65% fewer tokens on complex tasks
- Production code deserves the best model: all language pros now on Opus
- All code review uses Opus for maximum quality and security
- Sonnet > Haiku (38 vs 31) ensures better intelligence for support tasks
- Inherit tier gives users cost control for frontend, mobile, and specialized tasks

Related: #136, #132

* feat: upgrade final 13 agents from Haiku to Sonnet

Based on research into Haiku 4.5 vs Sonnet 4.5 capabilities, upgraded
agents requiring deep analytical intelligence from Haiku to Sonnet.

Research Findings:
- Haiku 4.5: 73.3% SWE-bench, 3-5x faster, 1/3 cost, sub-200ms responses
- Best for Haiku: Real-time apps, data extraction, templates, high-volume ops
- Best for Sonnet: Complex reasoning, root cause analysis, strategic planning

Agents Upgraded (13 total):
- Debugging (5): debugger (2), error-detective (3) - Complex root cause analysis
- DevOps (3): devops-troubleshooter (3) - System diagnostics & troubleshooting
- Network (2): network-engineer (2) - Complex network analysis & optimization
- API Documentation (2): api-documenter (2) - Deep API understanding required
- Payments (1): payment-integration - Critical financial integration

Final Distribution (153 total):
- Tier 1 Opus: 42 agents (27.5%) - Production coding + critical architecture
- Tier 2 Inherit: 42 agents (27.5%) - Complex tasks, user-choosable
- Tier 3 Sonnet: 51 agents (33.3%) - Support tasks needing intelligence
- Tier 4 Haiku: 18 agents (11.8%) - Fast operational tasks only

Haiku Now Reserved For:
- SEO/Marketing (8): Pattern matching, data extraction, content templates
- Deployment (4): Operational execution tasks
- Simple Docs (3): reference-builder, mermaid-expert, c4-code
- Sales/Support (2): High-volume, template-based interactions
- Search (1): Knowledge retrieval

Sonnet > Haiku as requested (51 vs 18)

Sources:
- https://www.creolestudios.com/claude-haiku-4-5-vs-sonnet-4-5-comparison/
- https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-haiku-4-5
- https://caylent.com/blog/claude-haiku-4-5-deep-dive-cost-capabilities-and-the-multi-agent-opportunity

Related: #136

* docs: add cost considerations and clarify inherit behavior

Addresses PR feedback:
- Added comprehensive cost comparison for all model tiers
- Documented how 'inherit' model works (uses session default, falls back to Sonnet)
- Explained cost optimization strategies
- Clarified when Opus token efficiency offsets higher rate

This helps users make informed decisions about model selection and cost control.
This commit is contained in:
Seth Hobson
2025-12-10 15:52:06 -05:00
committed by GitHub
parent 27a246a8c6
commit c7ad381360
108 changed files with 137 additions and 114 deletions

View File

@@ -1,10 +1,9 @@
# Claude Code Plugins: Orchestration and Automation
> **⚡ Updated for Opus 4.5, Sonnet 4.5 & Haiku 4.5** — Three-tier model strategy for optimal performance
[![Run in Smithery](https://smithery.ai/badge/skills/wshobson)](https://smithery.ai/skills?ns=wshobson&utm_source=github&utm_medium=badge)
> **⚡ Updated for Sonnet 4.5 & Haiku 4.5** — All agents optimized for latest models with hybrid orchestration
>
> **🎯 Agent Skills Enabled** — 47 specialized skills extend Claude's capabilities across plugins with progressive disclosure
A comprehensive production-ready system combining **91 specialized AI agents**, **15 multi-agent workflow orchestrators**, **47 agent skills**, and **45 development tools** organized into **65 focused, single-purpose plugins** for [Claude Code](https://docs.claude.com/en/docs/claude-code/overview).
@@ -125,15 +124,39 @@ Specialized knowledge packages following Anthropic's progressive disclosure arch
[→ View complete skills documentation](docs/agent-skills.md)
### Hybrid Model Orchestration
### Three-Tier Model Strategy
Strategic model assignment for optimal performance and cost:
- **48 Haiku agents** - Fast execution for deterministic tasks
- **100 Sonnet agents** - Complex reasoning and architecture
| Tier | Model | Agents | Use Case |
|------|-------|--------|----------|
| **Tier 1** | Opus 4.5 | 42 | Critical architecture, security, ALL code review, production coding (language pros, frameworks) |
| **Tier 2** | Inherit | 42 | Complex tasks - user chooses model (AI/ML, backend, frontend/mobile, specialized) |
| **Tier 3** | Sonnet | 51 | Support with intelligence (docs, testing, debugging, network, API docs, DX, legacy, payments) |
| **Tier 4** | Haiku | 18 | Fast operational tasks (SEO, deployment, simple docs, sales, content, search) |
**Why Opus 4.5 for Critical Agents?**
- 80.9% on SWE-bench (industry-leading)
- 65% fewer tokens for complex tasks
- Best for architecture decisions and security audits
**Tier 2 Flexibility (`inherit`):**
Agents marked `inherit` use your session's default model, letting you balance cost and capability:
- Set via `claude --model opus` or `claude --model sonnet` when starting a session
- Falls back to Sonnet 4.5 if no default specified
- Perfect for frontend/mobile developers who want cost control
- AI/ML engineers can choose Opus for complex model work
**Cost Considerations:**
- **Opus 4.5**: $5/$25 per million input/output tokens - Premium for critical work
- **Sonnet 4.5**: $3/$15 per million tokens - Balanced performance/cost
- **Haiku 4.5**: $1/$5 per million tokens - Fast, cost-effective operations
- Opus's 65% token reduction on complex tasks often offsets higher rate
- Use `inherit` tier to control costs for high-volume use cases
Orchestration patterns combine models for efficiency:
```
Sonnet (planning) → Haiku (execution) → Sonnet (review)
Opus (architecture) → Sonnet (development) → Haiku (deployment)
```
[→ View model configuration details](docs/agents.md#model-configuration)